The Convention Against Torture: What Canada Committed to in 1987 & What It Means Today

UN CAT, the Inter-American Convention, and Canada’s Obligations in Immigration and Asylum Law

Canada became a state party to the Convention Against Torture on June 24, 1987 – the same month the treaty took effect globally. From that date forward, Article 3 imposed a clear prohibition: no person may be removed from Canada to a country where substantial grounds exist to believe that person would face torture. The prohibition carries no carve-out for criminal record, no exception for national security grounds. That unconditional character is precisely why Article 3 generates more Canadian courtroom litigation than any other provision of the treaty.

The UN Convention Against Torture: Scope and Core Obligations

The full title of the instrument is the Convention Against Torture (CAT) and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment. The UN General Assembly adopted it on December 10, 1984. It entered into force on June 26, 1987. By 2025, ratifications had reached 157 states.

The treaty’s structure follows three parallel tracks of obligation: establishing a legal definition of torture and requiring its criminalization in domestic law; prohibiting the transfer of individuals to situations where torture would occur; and creating a monitoring system through which state compliance is assessed.

The Definition of Torture (Article 1)

Article 1 provides the operative definition. Torture means any act that intentionally inflicts severe pain or suffering, whether physical or psychological, on a person, where that act is carried out by a public official or with the consent or acquiescence of one, and where the purpose is to extract information or a confession, to punish, to intimidate, to coerce, or to discriminate. Two limits in the definition warrant attention. The first is the state-actor requirement: suffering caused entirely by private individuals, with no official involvement at any level, may fall outside Article 1’s scope, though other provisions of the CAT can still apply. The second is the lawful sanctions exclusion: pain or suffering that is inherent in or incidental to a legally authorized penalty does not qualify as torture under the Convention’s terms.

Stark interrogation room with handcuffs on a chair, a prohibited techniques poster, a surveillance camera, and an open legal text

Article 1, Convention Against Torture – Definition

Under Article 1, torture means the intentional infliction of severe pain or suffering, physical or psychological, by or with the acquiescence of «a public official or other person acting in an official capacity», for purposes including extracting information, punishment, intimidation, or discrimination. Pain inherent in lawful sanctions falls outside the definition. Full text available at ohchr.org.

Border wall at dusk with a chained gate, deportation order, abandoned passport and belongings beneath a no exceptional circumstances sign

The Absolute Prohibition (Articles 2 and 3)

Article 2 establishes the absolute prohibition: “No exceptional circumstances whatsoever, whether a state of war or a threat of war, internal political instability or any other public emergency, may be invoked as a justification of torture.” Article 3 extends this absolutely to expulsion, return, and extradition: no state party may return a person to another state where there are substantial grounds for believing they would be subjected to torture. Unlike refugee law, there is no exception in Article 3 for criminals or security threats. The Convention is clear on this.

Article 16 extends the prohibition beyond “torture” as defined in Article 1 to cover other acts of cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment that do not meet the severity threshold for torture but are still prohibited.

Canada and the CAT: Ratification and Domestic Law

Canada signed the CAT on August 23, 1985, and ratified it on June 24, 1987 – before the Convention had even been in force for a month. Canada entered no significant reservations. It has accepted the Committee Against Torture’s competence to receive individual complaints under Article 22.

IRPA Section 97: The CAT in Canadian Law

The primary domestic implementation of CAT Article 3 is in the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, section 97(1)(a). That provision designates as a “person in need of protection” any person whose removal from Canada would subject them personally to “a danger, believed on substantial grounds to exist, of torture within the meaning of Article 1 of the Convention Against Torture.” The Article 1 CAT definition is reproduced in a Schedule to the IRPA. This means the legal test for a s. 97(1)(a) claim tracks the Article 1 CAT definition directly.

The standard is “substantial grounds to exist,” interpreted by courts as equivalent to the balance of probabilities – the danger of torture must be more likely than not. This is a higher threshold than the “serious possibility” standard under the refugee definition in s. 96. Section 97 protection is therefore narrower in scope but covers people who may not qualify as Convention refugees under s. 96.

IRPA Section 115: The Non-Refoulement Provision and Its Exceptions

Section 115(1) of IRPA reflects the CAT’s non-refoulement obligation: protected persons and recognized refugees cannot be removed to countries where they face persecution, torture, or cruel and unusual treatment. But s. 115(2) creates exceptions – it does not apply to persons inadmissible on grounds of serious criminality who constitute a danger to the public, or persons inadmissible on security grounds. This exception is potentially inconsistent with CAT Article 3’s absolute prohibition, and the Committee Against Torture has raised this concern in periodic reviews of Canada.

The Supreme Court of Canada in Suresh v. Canada [2002] 1 SCR 3 confirmed that returning someone to a substantial risk of torture would ordinarily violate s. 7 of the Charter, but left open a narrow exception in “extraordinary circumstances” – a conclusion that remains contested in international human rights law.

Article 3 of the CAT is absolute: no exceptional circumstances justify return to torture. Canada’s IRPA s. 115(2) creates exceptions for security cases that the CAT does not permit. The Committee Against Torture has flagged this inconsistency in repeated reviews of Canada.

Non-Refoulement Under CAT: How It Differs from Refugee Convention Protection

The non-refoulement obligations in the CAT and in the Refugee Convention operate differently, and both may apply in a given case.

Refugee Convention: Persecution on Specific Grounds

Article 33 of the 1951 Refugee Convention prohibits return to persecution on grounds of race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group, or political opinion. The risk must be persecution, not just harm. It has exceptions for serious criminals who constitute a danger to national security.

CAT Article 3: Torture by Any State Official, for Any Reason

Article 3 of the CAT is broader in one respect and narrower in another. Broader: it applies regardless of why the torture would occur – there is no requirement to establish the political, racial, or religious motive that refugee law requires. Any risk of torture by state actors is covered. Narrower: it requires the risk be torture specifically, not merely persecution or serious harm. And, as noted, the CAT in theory admits no exception for security cases.

In Canadian proceedings, claimants can succeed under s. 97(1)(a) (CAT-based) without meeting the refugee definition under s. 96. They can also succeed under both simultaneously if the evidence supports it. For practitioners: a client who fears state-inflicted torture but whose claim does not fit a Convention ground may succeed on the CAT ground alone.

The Inter-American Convention to Prevent and Punish Torture

A parallel instrument exists within the OAS framework. The Inter-American Convention to Prevent and Punish Torture was adopted at Cartagena de Indias, Colombia, on December 9, 1985, and entered into force on February 28, 1987 – making it almost exactly contemporaneous with the UN CAT. Around 18 Latin American OAS member states are parties to it. Canada is not.

A Broader Definition

The Inter-American Convention’s definition of torture is notably broader than the UN CAT’s. It explicitly includes “the use of methods upon a person intended to obliterate the personality of the victim or to diminish his physical or mental capacities, even if they do not cause physical pain or mental anguish.” Systematic sensory deprivation, extreme psychological disorientation, and similar techniques may fall within this broader definition even where they would not clearly meet the Article 1 CAT threshold. This expansion reflects the documented practices of Latin American security services in the 1970s and 1980s – the context in which the convention was drafted.

Canada, as a non-party, is not bound by the Inter-American Convention. But its broader definition has been cited in academic literature and international proceedings when interpreting the scope of torture prohibitions generally.

Hands comparing the Inter-American and UN Conventions against Torture with a magnifying glass beside Latin American country case files

The Committee Against Torture: Monitoring, Reviews, and Individual Complaints

The Committee Against Torture (CAT Committee) is the treaty body that monitors state parties’ compliance with the Convention. It has four main functions relevant to Canada.

Periodic Reviews

State parties must submit periodic reports on their implementation of the Convention. Canada has been reviewed multiple times. The Committee’s concluding observations on Canada have repeatedly raised concerns about: the s. 115(2) IRPA exception for security cases; incomplete incorporation of the CAT definition into domestic law; and the treatment of persons subject to security certificates. All concluding observations are publicly available at the OHCHR’s Treaty Body Database.

Individual Complaints (Article 22)

Canada accepted the competence of the Committee to receive individual complaints under Article 22. This means anyone subject to Canadian jurisdiction who believes their CAT rights have been violated can submit a communication to the Committee, after exhausting domestic remedies. The Committee’s views are not legally binding in the way a court judgment is, but they carry significant persuasive authority and are published.

OPCAT: What Canada Committed To

The Optional Protocol to the Convention Against Torture (OPCAT) creates the Subcommittee on Prevention of Torture (SPT) – an independent body that conducts unannounced visits to places of detention in states parties to monitor conditions. As of October 2025, 95 states have ratified OPCAT. Canada has not ratified OPCAT. At its fourth Universal Periodic Review in November 2023, Canada committed before the UN Human Rights Council to ratify OPCAT. That commitment has not yet been fulfilled as of April 2026.

If you are facing removal and fear torture

This page is informational. If you are in Canada and face deportation to a country where you believe you would be tortured, you may be able to seek protection under IRPA s. 97(1)(a). Eligibility depends on your specific facts. Contact a licensed immigration lawyer or a legal aid clinic before any removal proceedings. UNHCR Canada can also provide referrals.

Sources: OHCHR Treaty Body Database • Immigration and Refugee Board Legal Concepts, Chapter 14 • IRPA s. 97 and s. 115 (Justice Canada, laws-lois.justice.gc.ca) • Suresh v. Canada (MCI) [2002] 1 SCR 3 • Canadian Council for Refugees, CAT Compliance Comments (2005) • OAS Basic Documents: Inter-American Convention to Prevent and Punish Torture • Wikipedia: OPCAT (October 2025) • Global Affairs Canada: Human Rights Treaties • Canada UPR 4th Cycle commitments (2023)